Schaefer Mixtape: What Are Draft Experts Saying About Likely No. 1 Pick?

Matthew Schaefer looks set to be the No. 1 pick of the 2025 Draft.

In that case, the San Jose Sharks with the second-overall selection will likely miss out on adding a much-needed premier defensive prospect.

That said, there’s still a chance that the New York Islanders pass on the blueliner…wouldn’t that make Sharks GM Mike Grier’s day?

In that case, here’s what the San Jose Sharks could be getting.

Courtesy of Matt Meagher — follow Matt on Twitter and YouTube — here’s his Schaefer mixtape:

Also, here’s what some of the top Draft experts are saying about the 6-foot-2 left-hander.

Elite Prospects: “All the makings of a franchise-altering No. 1 defenceman in the NHL.”

Chris Peters, FloHockey: “He impressed many at the combine with his personal story and the incredible resilience he’s shown in his life.”

Steven Ellis, Daily Faceoff: “There isn’t a better, more deceptive skater on the blueline in this draft class, with his mobility being among the best we’ve seen in recent draft classes.”

Craig Button, TSN: “I see Schaefer as Drew Doughty-like.”

Brock Otten, McKeen’s Hockey: “A future perennial all-star who can play in all situations and be your future captain.”

Scott Wheeler, The Athletic: “The world loves Schaefer. He is going No. 1.”

Corey Pronman, The Athletic: “He projects as a star No. 1 defenseman in the NHL.”

Jason Bukala, Sportsnet: “He’s elite in every skill category.

Next mixtape up is a more likely San Jose Sharks pick…Michael Misa!