Film Room
Quick Thoughts: Is Balcers a Top-6 Forward on Sharks?
Is Rudolfs Balcers a top-six forward for the San Jose Sharks?
In terms of productivity and skill, he’s got a good argument.
He’s seventh among San Jose forwards with 0.44 Points Per Game, behind, naturally, the Sharks’ clear top-five of Evander Kane, Tomas Hertl, Logan Couture, Timo Meier, and Kevin Labanc. Ryan Donato is a shade ahead of Balcers at 0.45.
More impressively, he’s fifth with 1.87 Points Per 60 at 5-on-5, behind Labanc, Kane, Couture, and Hertl.
As for the eye test, Balcers and Donato have comparable skill, but Balcers is better defensively. Dylan Gambrell and Matt Nieto are more trusted, but they’re defensive specialists, lacking anything close to Balcers or Donato’s offensive upside.
On one hand, what a coup by Doug Wilson, to pluck a possible top-nine forward from waivers. On the other hand – let’s be honest – Balcers is not in the conversation for top-six forward on a deeper team.
That’s not a knock on the 23-year-old forward, who’s revitalized his career after being released by Ottawa. He’s a clear NHL talent — this isn’t his first impressive game.
We saw some of that talent on display early in last night’s 4-0 loss to Arizona.
00:03 Balcers (92) uses his speed to cut off Jason Demers (55), who’s trying to come out of the corner.
00:15 Balcers is battling with Jordan Oesterle (82) in front of the net. Look how hard he’s working to get open: He feints toward the high slot, before cutting back to the paint. As a Brent Burns (88) shot-pass skitters forward, Balcers stick checks Oesterle, making sure the shot gets through and Adin Hill has to make a save.
00:25 The Latvian winger ferrets out a loose puck off the wall.
00:30 Off the Tomas Hertl (48) tip, Balcers beats John Hayden (15) to another loose puck.
00:38 So far in his brief San Jose Sharks stint, Balcers has shown a nose for finding the soft spots. He finds it between four Coyotes. That is a hard pass for Hertl to complete though.
00:42 But as Hertl circles the net, Balcers is right time, right place for the rebound. It’s not counted as a shot, but it looks like Balcers snaps it off Hill.
According to the league’s play-by-play sheet, Balcers was a non-entity on this shift – no shots, shot attempts, hits, etc. – but that’s obviously not accurate. When he’s on, he’s fast, strong, and tenacious on the puck.
That’s the good. But there’s a bad – remember that Balcers, before this year, had just parts of two NHL campaigns under the belt. The 23-year-old still has something to learn, in terms of consistency and maturity.
It’s not just the two minor penalties that he took, which blunted the San Jose Sharks’ momentum in a must-win game – it’s the body language:
That’s, frankly, immature – the play is still going, you have to keep your feet moving. To Balcers’s credit, he does get back into the play, but this is clearly a learning moment.
As I noted, on a good team, he shouldn’t be your sixth-best forward, not even arguably.
But good news for the San Jose Sharks? If the impending RFA reaches his potential, he’ll be well worth the wait.
Ask Jasper Weatherby Anything | SJHN+
If Sharks Want to Take Next Step, They’ll Need to Add Scoring
Notes #24: Rangers Shut Out Sharks
Don’t Disregard Anna Kane + Knyzhov Injury Update
Preview/Lines #24: Middleton “Having the Time of His Life” Alongside Karlsson
“Cheating” Sharks Get What They Deserve
REPORT: Friedman Says Sharks Will Retain Salary to Trade Kane
Which Eastern Conference Team Wants to Trade for Kane?
Eklund, Agent Believe He Should Be in NHL — Sharks Disagreed
Sharks Have “Faded Away” From Their Identity
Don’t Disregard Anna Kane + Knyzhov Injury Update
Sharks @ Islanders Review: Timo, Good Defense All You Need?
Sharks @ Islanders/Rangers Previews
Sharks @ Devils Recap: The Most Complete Game of the Season?
Sharks @ Devils Preview: Can Power Play Start Clicking?
I’ve been thinking about this more since Balcers returned, and I do think he might well be a true-talent middle six forward, which is pretty huge for this club. But I’ve also been getting more frustrated lately at the forward deployment by Boughner, burying guys like Donato and Leonard (and even Balcers a bit) deep in the lineup on lines with Gabriel and others to not exactly play to their strengths. I get that both of these guys, and Leonard, too, have defensive issues and maybe even some compete issues to work on (less so with Leonard; he’s just inexperienced),… Read more »
Especially now, where we really can’t lose any more than we have. Let these kids get their chances and their lumps. They only grow with both feast and famine.
I would argue that Nieto, which I’ve written about, has actually been good in the top-6 — he was great at dirty work, getting pucks, drawing penalties, playing 200 feet. He’s obv not a legit top-6 option, but as a complementary player to skill guys, I liked him. It might’ve been just a good stretch and obv Nieto doesn’t have the hands to stay in top-6, but he earned his time there. Can’t say the same about Marleau. While I can hear a 5-on-5 argument for Marleau, I can’t think of a reason for Marleau to be ahead of Balcers… Read more »
PM was at least NHL level last season with the Sharks. he’s definitely fallen off a cliff this year.
Yeah, I like Nieto and can see what you mean about his role with the more skilled players. I just feel like at this point they’re better off getting other players more experience in those roles to kind of see how much they can actually bring in the long term with this club (Nieto is a free agent, after all, and though I wouldn’t be opposed to seeing him locked down for a couple years, they should probably see what kind of pick they could get for trading him, anyway.)
Well, they’re still trying to win, I think, so they just have to go with their best players in that case. That was Nieto playing higher up, so I have on problem with it
i know i’ve seen Leonard make defensive mistakes but his stats (xGA/60 is great and CA/60 is well above average). if anything, his offensive stats could use some work. Donato’s been productive on the PP but his EV stats aren’t good. Donato looks to me like a 3rd line PP specialist. Balcers is pretty “meh”. Nieto’s been playing up too high and his stats are well below what he produced the last couple of seasons in COL as a bottom 6F.
[…] San Jose: Fast Ideas–Is Rudy Balcers a top-six ahead? He’s making a case for it, anyway. […]
[…] Is Rudolfs Balcers a top-six forward for the San Jose Sharks? In terms of productivity and skill, he’s got a good argument. (San Jose Hockey Now) […]
[…] San Jose: Quick Thoughts–Is Rudy Balcers a top-six forward? He’s making a case for it, anyway. […]