Connect with us


Sheng’s Daily: What’s Realistic Sharks Trade for Eichel?



Pierre LeBrun connected the San Jose Sharks with Jack Eichel two weeks ago.

“I wonder if at some level about San Jose,” LeBrun mused on the Sharks possibly dealing for Eichel. “Only because, depending on what ends up happening with Evander Kane. If Evander Kane is off the books in some way or another, depending on what the NHL decides, suddenly they got cap room and that Jack Eichel is 24 and the Sharks are trying to transition into a younger team. So I kind of wonder about them.”

This was on Oct. 15 — three days later, the NHL announced that Kane would be suspended for 21 games — but with no additional penalties.

In short, after Nov. 30, when Kane’s suspension is scheduled to end, he’s back on the salary cap for the remainder of this season and three more years.

That should dash any San Jose Sharks’ hopes for Eichel?

Maybe not — at least on the cap front.

Let’s say the Sharks continue to carry Kane’s cap hit after Nov. 30, be it with the Sharks, partially buried with the San Jose Barracuda, or basically paid to stay home.

Conceivably, if San Jose were able to pull off an Eichel trade, they could put the center’s $10 million cap hit on LTIR. Eichel, of course, could be out up to four months after getting the disk replacement surgery that he’s been seeking.

So irrelevant to what happens with Kane, that could solve Eichel’s 2021-22 cap hit.

Then in the off-season, they could buy out Kane, or hope to trade him with salary retained. At this point, the problem winger will have three years and $21 million dollars left on the books. A Kane buyout, by the way, won’t be pretty:


Of course, buying out Kane doesn’t come close to covering Eichel’s cap hit. But obviously, this isn’t a one-for-one situation. Just for example, the money you free up by letting impending UFA Tomas Hertl walk, $5.6 million this year, along with the savings from a Kane buyout, could more or less make up for Eichel’s AAV.

Anyway, this is all a longshot. The San Jose Sharks aren’t a likely winner of the Eichel sweepstakes: Their cap situation is concerning and they aren’t rich in young assets like other teams are.

But regardless, what would it take for them to land the star center?

Lance Lysowski of The Buffalo News wrote yesterday: “The timing and lack of suitors will force the Sabres to lower the asking price. Eichel’s no-movement clause kicks in this July, so Adams is slowly losing leverage. Few teams that can take on his salary and the Sabres reportedly have no interest in retaining money. In my opinion, the Sabres will acquire a first-round pick with conditions related to Eichel’s recovery, a high-end prospect, a middle-tier prospect with upside and a proven NHL player to help offset the cap hit.

“The Sabres need to add a forward who can score goals.”

Keep in mind that Lysowski is speculating — so I’ll do the same. Giving up a first-rounder for Eichel is a given, that shouldn’t be a problem for any team for a player of this caliber.

As for a high-end prospect, would the Sabres take anything less than William Eklund? You can offer a Thomas Bordeleau and see if they’d bite.

A middle-tier prospect with upside? Danil Gushchin, come on down.

A proven NHL scorer “to offset the cap hit”? A resurgent Timo Meier might suddenly intrigue a team.

If you were the San Jose Sharks, would you trade a conditional first-round pick, Bordeleau, Gushchin, and Meier for Eichel? What if Buffalo insists on Eklund instead of Bordeleau?

At San Jose Hockey Now…

Thank You, Readers + Sheng Eats His Way Through Montreal

SOURCE: Mike Richards-Like Settlement Between Sharks & Kane Not Likely

Welcome Cathy’s Power Skating & Extra Hour Training!

Jack Han Doesn’t Think Karlsson Is Still a Top-Pairing D-Man

What’s Different About Sharks Power Play? | SJHN+

What Aren’t We Hearing From Sharks About Kane?

Sheng’s Tip Jar

Season Preview: Barracuda Ready for Return to Normalcy with Deep Roster

Pat Falloon’s Advice for William Eklund

SJHN’s Top-10 Sharks Prospects + McKenna Talks Hill’s Pros & Cons

Sharks’ Weekend Recap

Sharks Mailbag: What Can Hertl Fetch? What Are We Worried About This Year?

In other San Jose Sharks news…

Patrick Bacon doesn’t believe in the Erik Karlsson comeback narrative. (Topdown Hockey)

Home and back again: How Jonathan Dahlen persevered to break into the NHL. (Fear the Fin)

Christian Eklund talks about his son William Eklund’s meteoric rise to the NHL. (San Francisco Chronicle)

Around the NHL…

Joe Thornton scores his first Florida Panthers goal:

Colin Wilson shares his battle with addiction. (Players’ Tribune)

The top-23 prospects of the 2022 NHL Draft. (The Athletic)

RGV Roller is fighting to reignite interest in hockey in south Texas. (Sportsnet)

It’s early, but NHL attendance woes are cause for concern. (The Athletic)

Want to learn about the untold contributions of Indigenous people in hockey? (Fear the Fin)

The Perfection Line shines in the Boston Bruins‘ 4-3 victory over the San Jose Sharks:

Talking Points: Perfection Line Shines, Bruins Hold Off Sharks 4-3

Elliotte Friedman says the Calgary Flames are very interested in Eichel:

Friedman says Flames top list of Eichel interest, could Calgary make trade work?

Terry Frei reminds Colorado Avalanche fans: The DoPS doesn’t have it out for your team.

Frei column: No, the NHL DoPS doesn’t have it out for your team (it just seems like it)

Four-point game puts Lucas Raymond alongside Detroit Red Wings‘ legends:

4 Point Game Puts Rookie Lucas Raymond Alongside Red Wings Legends

Jonathan Huberdeau is a not-so-secret weapon on the Florida Panthers’ penalty kill.

Jonathan Huberdeau: A not-so-secret weapon on the Panthers’ penalty kill

Could Patrick Roy take over the Montreal Canadiens?

Gallo: Patrick Roy rumours, bring the circus to town

What we’ve learned about the New York Islanders after six games.

What We’ve Learned About the New York Islanders After 6 Games

Pittsburgh Penguins head coach Mike Sullivan calls the recent wins “rewarding,” but…

Penguins Discuss Ways to Avoid Injuries; Sullivan Calls Wins ‘Rewarding,’ but…

Early slump has heat building on the Toronto Maple Leafs.

Early slump has heat building on Toronto Maple Leafs

Vancouver Canucks star Elias Pettersson needs time and protection.

Elias Pettersson Needs Time and Protection (+)

The last-place Vegas Golden Knights could be in trouble: Max Pacioretty is now on LTIR.

Max Pacioretty Placed on LTIR: Golden Knights Free Up Cap Space

Alex Ovechkin is off to his best start yet for the Washington Capitals:

‘You Can See The Jump’: At 36, Ovechkin Off To Best Start Yet With Capitals

Welcome to your new home for San Jose Sharks breaking news, analysis and opinion. Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter and don't forget to subscribe to SJHN+ for all of our members-only content from Sheng Peng and the National Hockey Now network plus an ad-free browsing experience.
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Don’t want Eichel anywhere near this team, given his rumoured poor reputation in locker room getting rid of Kane to bring in Eichel seems moronic

timorous me

I just think that when you look at what the Sharks would probably end up losing in an Eichel trade–I’m including Hertl since it seems he’d likely end up not being able to be re-signed–it feels like the kind of situation that could end up turning out really poorly for the Sharks going forward. Not to say they’re in great shape as it is, but I wouldn’t want to lose Timo (a possiblity), Hertl, and maybe Bordeleau and Guschkin. It just feels wrong for where the Sharks are. And we know Eichel can only do so much with a team… Read more »

[…] Peng in San Jose examines a potential Eichel trade for the Sharks and tries to find a way to get it done without including rookie winger William […]


having to retain salary for kane is a ridiculous proposition imho .as a player he is not mike richards: not on drugs in a career-ending decline. at worst even “giving” kane away for a 3+ rounder is a great deal for a goal starved team (montreal , az, etc). kane is at least a 20 , “30-if-good-year” scorer …. thats somewhere between “good” and “elite” ….for 7 mil a year thats a basement bargain these days (if looking at price alone)…. even with “baggage” its still a “decent to very-good” deal. the eichel price has dropped recently which is great… Read more »

david barnard

Giroux (33), Bergeron (36), Hertl (28), Malkin (35); then Strome (28), Domi (26), Trocheck (28), and Kadri (31) pretty sure Bergeron stays in BOS. Giroux’s future believe it or not is uncertain with the Flyers. Malkin’s gonna have to take less to play in PIT, but will probably stay with Crosby and Letang. i think Domi was bouncing around lines at LW before he got hurt. still he’s a natural center and played there last season. Trocheck’s could be on the move, or Kotkaniemi could be picked off potentially. i’m not if he’s UFA or RFA? they could bring back… Read more »

Last edited 1 month ago by david barnard

so basically the pool of ufa dominant 1c is thin and hertl is the best one ….. malkin , G and bergeron are great , but past their peak, so short-term option “B” at best. kadri is another kane in the making….domi , strome and trockeck are serviceable but not top tier material…. borde is 6+ years away from being a 1c center …4+ to line 2c AT BEST IF things go well (no injuries and continued phys+mental development) mind you- couture will be 35 in 3 years, so the age-decline is nigh..he became 1c when jumbo was around that… Read more »

david barnard

Bordeleau’s trajectory is top line center, perhaps even super star status if all the stars align. JE is an NHL super star. however, i think there are many questions+baggage that comes with him. i’d rather this team stay on the path of the rebuild. RW is looking really solid in the pipeline (Robins, Guschin, Wiesblatt, and Coe are all on upward trajectories). LW with Eklund and Dahlen. Gregor is off to another strong start w/the Cuda at center. he might be a future 3C. if we don’t make the playoffs, so what? we’re probably not bad enough to get in… Read more »

Sheng’s Travel Fund

Help fund Sheng's travel! Every dollar goes to the cost of getting to and from Sharks road games.

Click here to contribute to Sheng's travel pool!

Get SJHN in your inbox!

Enter your email address to get all of our articles delivered directly to your inbox.

Extra Hour Hockey Training

Cathy’s Power Skating

Sharks Team & Cap Info

SJHN on Facebook

All the San Jose Sharks news that's fit to print

Enter your email to get the best Sharks coverage delivered straight to your inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.